The Big Lie
Ernest Partridge, Co-Editor
The Crisis Papers
April 12, 2011
||In a time of deceit, telling the
truth is a revolutionary act.
Is there any limit to the outrageousness of the GOP lies?
Is there any limit to the capacity of a large number of our fellow citizens
to accept these lies?
If it were in the interest of the ruling oligarchs to convince a majority
of the public that the earth is flat, could they succeed?
This is, after all, a public almost half of which refuses to accept
evolution – the central coordinating concept of modern biology. And
approximately half of the GOP primary voters believe that Barack Obama was
not born in the United States.
These unsettling thoughts came to my mind when I heard
that "not in the history of mankind has the government ever created a job."
This from a man who held a government job as Lieutenant Governor of
That remark was echoed by
the Governor of Indiana and Sarah Palin and I can testify that I have
heard it elsewhere.
Michael Steele's comment is more audacious even than the claim that the earth is flat.
(After all, the earth looks flat, doesn’t it?). To say that government never
created a single job flies in the face of ordinary, everyday experience.
What are police, firefighters, teachers, judges, prosecutors, postal
workers, military personnel, etc engaged in if not “government jobs.” What
is the construction and maintenance of roads and bridges, the certification
of the safety of our food and drugs, air traffic control, if they are not
The claim that government never creates jobs is so preposterous that it
seems pointless even to bother to refute it.
Yet somehow, some GOP politicians freely utter this absurdity without fear
of being laughed off the stage of public debate. And apparently some people,
failing to give the claim even a moment’s critical reflection, believe it.
Otherwise, why would Steele and others say such nonsense in the first place.
And this is only the most egregious of a long string of Republican lies
thrown at the public by right-wing politicians and pundits and largely
unchallenged by a compliant corporate media. Among them:
Al Gore claimed to have invented the internet and to have discovered the
toxic contamination of Love Canal.
John Kerry’s allegedly heroic war record was fraudulent.
Barack Obama was born in Kenya and is a secret Muslim.
Saddam Hussein possessed weapons of mass destruction and was involved in
the attacks of September 11, 2001.
Global warming is a gigantic hoax, perpetrated by thousands of deceitful
Obama has raised taxes.
“Obamacare” is a “socialist government takeover of health care.”
Ninety percent of Planned Parenthood funding is for abortion services.
Elections in the United States are always accurate and fair.
These are not “matters of opinion,” they are flatly and demonstrably false.
Clear and decisive refutation of all these claims are available to anyone
who cares to examine the evidence. As Daniel Patrick Moynihan famously
remarked, while we are entitled to our own opinions, we are not entitled to
our own facts.
Then there are the contradictions:
Teachers, police officers and firefighters are greedy. But billionaire
CEOs and hedge-fund managers are not.
Wall street banksters are entitled to their million-dollar bonuses because
these bonuses are contractual obligations with their firms. But the states
are not required to honor their contractual obligations to public workers,
obligations such as pensions and health coverage.
Federal revenues are increased by cutting taxes (i.e., revenues).
During the Bush administration, “Reagan proved [that] deficits don’t
matter.” (Dick Cheney) In the Obama administration, the GOP tells us that
the federal deficit is the Number One economic problem today.
“Not in the history of mankind has the government ever created a job.”
(Michael Steele, etc.). “Since President Obama has taken office, the federal
government had added 200 thousand new federal jobs.” (John Boehner. Also
false, by the way. The correct number is 56,000).
And finally, there is the “dogma” – a priori “first principles” too sacred
to be doubted or subjected to rational analysis and confirmation:
“Government is not the solution to our problem, government is the
problem.” (Ronald Reagan).
Market fundamentalism: “A free market [co-ordinates] the activity of
millions of people, each seeking his own interest, in such a way as to make
everyone better off.” (Milton Friedman)
Privatization: "Whenever we find an
approach to the extension of private property rights [in the natural
environment,] we find superior results.” (Robert J. Smith).
“There is no such thing as society.” (Margaret Thatcher)
“There is no such entity as ‘the public.’” (Ayn Rand)
These last two dogmas
bear significant implications. For if there is no such thing as “society,” it
follows that there are no social problems or “social injustice. Poverty is the
fault of individuals who are sinful and lazy. And if there is no “public,” then
there is no “public interest,” and thus no need for government to promote same.
A large portion of the American public believes these lies, accepts these
contradictions, and embraces these dogmas, not because of supporting
evidence (there is none) or cogent arguments (there are none), but out of
sheer unquestioned repetition in the corporate media.
Students of propaganda methods call this “The Big Lie” – a term that has its
origins in the Nazi Regime.
Congressman Steve Cohen (Democrat,
Tennessee) correctly observed that when
the GOP claimed that “Obamacare” was “government takeover of health care,”
they were engaging in a “Big Lie.” Yet when he said this on the floor of the
House of Representatives, he was so mercilessly hounded by the media and his
colleagues, that he felt obliged to apologize.
So now the corporate media has, in effect, ruled the expression, “The Big
Lie,” out of bounds of polite political discourse, despite the fact that the
term precisely describes the successful method of the right wing
propagandists. In short, those who wish to complain against this practice
have been effectively disarmed.
So where is the bewildered citizen to go if that citizen is to avoid the big
lies and to encounter a fund of verifiable facts and informed opinion? Rule
One: stay clear of the corporate media. Even The New York Times, once
regarded as “the newspaper of historical record,”
can no longer be trusted
to deliver “all the news that’s fit to print.” Remember the
hullabaloo about Bill Clinton’s “Whitewater” deal? Remember Judith Miller’s
breathless disclosure of Saddam Hussein’s nefarious “aluminum tubes”?
promoted by the New York Times. All false.
So where do we find authentic news? Try National Public Radio (while it
lasts) and, of course, the internet (until it is privatized and sold to the
media conglomerates) where one can find a multitude of independent
progressive websites. Also deserving honorable mention is the evening
contingent of MSNBC – O’Donnell, Maddow and Schultz. Even so, along with the
entire corporate media, these worthies never question the integrity of our
elections and only rarely discuss the size of the military budget, now
approximately equal all the other military budgets in the world combined,
including those of our allies. It should be noted that NBC, the parent company of MSNBC, is half
owned by the world’s largest military contractor, General Electric.
In addition, some of the best sources of news are foreign – and all
available on the internet. They include the BBC (England) and the CBC
(Canada), The Real News (broadcast from Toronto, Canada), Al Jazeera
English, and, amazingly, Russia Today. The Russians, it seems, are returning
the favor that we bestowed upon them during the Soviet Era, when the U.S.
and Western Europe sent accurate news across “the iron curtain” via The
Voice of America and Radio Free Europe. Yes, it has come to that!
But these are all pathetically weak voices accessed by thousands, arrayed
against the corporate media that is devoured by millions. And as long as
this remains the case, and those millions accept uncritically the lies,
myths and dogmas fed to them by the mega-corporations that own our
government, there appears to be little hope of a return to economic justice
and democratic government that we once enjoyed in the United States of
But all is not lost. As the folk tale of the boy who cried “Wolf!” reminds
us, liars tend through time to lose their credibility. We should strive to
accelerate this process as it applies to the corporate media by exposing the
lies and boycotting the sponsors of those who tell the lies.
The experience of the Russians is instructive. My Russian friends tell me
that after decades of unabashed lying by Pravda, Izvestia and Gostelradio,
fewer and fewer Soviet citizens believed the state media. The facts bear
them out, as history discloses that Russians instead sought out foreign
sources of news such as The Voice of America and Radio Free Europe. (See my
“What if America Loses its Voice?”). Some Russians were so desperate
for authentic news and uncensored opinion that they risked arrest and prison
by producing and distributing underground manuscripts, "Samizdat,"
hand to hand. In the United States today, a comparable "American
Samizdat" can be found on the internet.
When the Soviet government lost control of the hearts and minds of its
citizens, its days were numbered.
In the United States, the corporate media, unlike the Communist Party of the
Soviet Union, is sensitive to market forces. As ever more Americans refuse
to believe the lies served up by the corporate media, the media will either
reform or become politically irrelevant, and more and more attention will be
directed to responsible sources of news, both foreign and domestic. The fate
of Glenn Beck’s TV show and the diminishing audience of Fox “News” may be
harbingers of such reform.
Whatever the outcome, Thomas Jefferson’s warning remains enduringly true:
“If a nation expects to be ignorant and free, in a state of civilization, it
expects what never was and never will be.”
The restoration of sanity in our public discourse is essential to the
restoration of our democracy. Necessary, but not sufficient. In addition,
the liars in public offices must be removed from those offices. And that
will only happen
if official election returns can once again be trusted to
reflect the will of the voters, and not the output of secret software
written by right wing partisans.
But that is a huge topic that deserves a separate essay – perhaps the next.
Copyright 2011 by Ernest Partridge
Dr. Ernest Partridge is a consultant, writer and lecturer in the field
of Environmental Ethics and Public Policy. He has taught Philosophy at
the University of California, and in Utah, Colorado and Wisconsin. He
publishes the website, "The Online
Gadfly" and co-edits the progressive website,
"The Crisis Papers".
Send E-Mail to: email@example.com .